Order picking problems under weight, fragility, and category constraints

Warehouse order picking activities are among the ones that impact the most the bottom lines of warehouses. They are known to often account for more than half of the total warehousing costs. New practices and innovations generate new challenges for managers and open new research avenues. Many practical constraints arising in real-life have often been neglected in the scientific literature. We introduce, model, and solve a rich order picking problem under weight, fragility, and category constraints, motivated by our observation of a real-life application arising in the grocery retail industry. This difficult warehousing problem combines complex picking and routing decisions under the objective of minimizing the distance traveled. We first provide a full description of the warehouse design which enables us to algebraically compute the distances between all pairs of products. We then propose two distinct mathematical models to formulate the problem. We develop five heuristic methods, including extensions of the classical largest gap, mid point, S-shape, and combined heuristics. The fifth one is an implementation of the powerful adaptive large neighborhood search algorithm specifically designed for the problem at hand. We then implement a branch-and-cut algorithm and cutting planes to solve the two formulations. The performance of the proposed solution methods is assessed on a newly generated and realistic test bed containing up to 100 pickups and seven aisles. We compare the bounds provided by the two formulations. Our in-depth analysis shows which formulation tends to perform better. Extensive computational experiments confirm the efficiency of the ALNS matheuristic and derive some important insights for managing order picking in this kind of warehouses

A unified matheuristic for solving multi-constrained traveling salesman problems with profits

International audienceIn this paper, we address a rich Traveling Salesman Problem with Profits encountered in several real-life cases. We propose a unified solution approach based on variable neighborhood search. Our approach combines several removal and insertion routing neighborhoods and efficient constraint checking procedures. The loading problem related to the use of a multi-compartment vehicle is addressed carefully. Two loading neighborhoods based on the solution of mathematical programs are proposed to intensify the search. They interact with the routing neighborhoods as it is commonly done in matheuristics. The performance of the proposed matheuristic is assessed on various instances proposed for the Orienteer-ing Problem and the Orienteering Problem with Time Window including up to 288 customers. The computational results show that the proposed matheuristic is very competitive compared with the state-of-the-art methods. To better evaluate its performance, we generate a new testbed including instances with various attributes. Extensive computational experiments on the new testbed confirm the efficiency of the matheuristic. A sensitivity analysis highlights which components of the matheuristic contribute most to the solution quality

Unified matheuristic for solving rich vehicle routing problems

L’objectif de cette thèse est de développer un cadre méthodologique pour les problèmes de tournées de véhicules riches (RVRPs). Nous présentons d’abord une taxonomie et une définition élaborée des RVRPs basée sur une analyse typologique réalisée en fonction de deux critères discriminatoires. Dans cette thèse, nous nous intéressons à la résolution du problème de tournées de véhicules multi-dépôt multi-compartiment multi-produits avec fenêtres de temps (MDMCMCm-VRPTW). Nous proposons une heuristique de génération de colonnes unifiée qui inclut une matheuristique de type VNS. La matheuristique combine plusieurs heuristiques de routage de type destruction et insertion ainsi que des procédures efficaces de contrôle de réalisabilité des contraintes afin de résoudre le MDMCMCm-VRPTW pour un seul véhicule. Deux voisinages de chargement, basés sur la résolution de programmes mathématiques sont proposées. Des études expérimentales approfondies sont conduites sur un ensemble de 191 instances pour des VRPs moins complexes. Les expérimentations valident la compétitivité de la matheuristique unifiée. Une analyse de sensibilité révèle l’importance de certains choix algorithmiques et des voisinages de chargement pour parvenir à des solutions de très bonne qualité. La matheuristique basée sur la méthode de VNS est intégrée dans l’heuristique de génération de colonnes pour résoudre le MDMCMCm-VRPTW. Nous proposons une méthode exacte de post-traitement capable d’optimiser l’affectation des clients aux tournées de véhicules. Enfin, nous résolvons un RVRP qui survient dans le processus de collecte de l’huile d’olive en Tunisie à l’aide d’un algorithme exact de type branch-and-cutThe purpose of this thesis is to develop a solution framework for Rich Vehicle Routing Problems (RVRPs). We first provide a comprehensive survey of the RVRP literature as well as a taxonomy. Selected papers addressing various variants are classified according to the proposed taxonomy. A cluster analysis based on two discriminating criteria is performed and leads to define RVRPs. In this thesis we are interested in solving a multi-depot multi-compartment multi-commodity vehicle routing problem with time windows (MDMCMCm-VRPTW). We propose a unified column generation heuristic cooperating with a variable neighborhood search (VNS) matheuristic. The VNS combines several removal and insertion routing heuristics as well as computationally efficient constraint checking. Two loading neighborhoods based on the solution of mathematical programs are proposed to intensify the search. On a set of 191 instances of less complex routing problems, the unified matheuristic turns to be competitive. A sensitivity analysis, performed on more complex generated instances reveals the importance of some algorithmic features and of loading neighborhoods for reaching high quality solutions. The VNS based matheuristic is embedded in a column generation heuristic to solve the MDMCMCm-VRPTW. We propose an exact post-processing method to optimize the assignment ofcustomers to vehicle routes. Last, we introduce, model and solve to optimality a RVRP arising in the olive oil collection process in Tunisia. We propose an exact branch-and-cut algorithm to solve the problem. We evaluate the performance of the algorithm on real data sets under different transportation scenario

Une matheuristique unifiée pour résoudre des problèmes de tournées de véhicules riches

The purpose of this thesis is to develop a solution framework for Rich Vehicle Routing Problems (RVRPs). We first provide a comprehensive survey of the RVRP literature as well as a taxonomy. Selected papers addressing various variants are classified according to the proposed taxonomy. A cluster analysis based on two discriminating criteria is performed and leads to define RVRPs. In this thesis we are interested in solving a multi-depot multi-compartment multi-commodity vehicle routing problem with time windows (MDMCMCm-VRPTW). We propose a unified column generation heuristic cooperating with a variable neighborhood search (VNS) matheuristic. The VNS combines several removal and insertion routing heuristics as well as computationally efficient constraint checking. Two loading neighborhoods based on the solution of mathematical programs are proposed to intensify the search. On a set of 191 instances of less complex routing problems, the unified matheuristic turns to be competitive. A sensitivity analysis, performed on more complex generated instances reveals the importance of some algorithmic features and of loading neighborhoods for reaching high quality solutions. The VNS based matheuristic is embedded in a column generation heuristic to solve the MDMCMCm-VRPTW. We propose an exact post-processing method to optimize the assignment ofcustomers to vehicle routes. Last, we introduce, model and solve to optimality a RVRP arising in the olive oil collection process in Tunisia. We propose an exact branch-and-cut algorithm to solve the problem. We evaluate the performance of the algorithm on real data sets under different transportation scenariosL’objectif de cette thèse est de développer un cadre méthodologique pour les problèmes de tournées de véhicules riches (RVRPs). Nous présentons d’abord une taxonomie et une définition élaborée des RVRPs basée sur une analyse typologique réalisée en fonction de deux critères discriminatoires. Dans cette thèse, nous nous intéressons à la résolution du problème de tournées de véhicules multi-dépôt multi-compartiment multi-produits avec fenêtres de temps (MDMCMCm-VRPTW). Nous proposons une heuristique de génération de colonnes unifiée qui inclut une matheuristique de type VNS. La matheuristique combine plusieurs heuristiques de routage de type destruction et insertion ainsi que des procédures efficaces de contrôle de réalisabilité des contraintes afin de résoudre le MDMCMCm-VRPTW pour un seul véhicule. Deux voisinages de chargement, basés sur la résolution de programmes mathématiques sont proposées. Des études expérimentales approfondies sont conduites sur un ensemble de 191 instances pour des VRPs moins complexes. Les expérimentations valident la compétitivité de la matheuristique unifiée. Une analyse de sensibilité révèle l’importance de certains choix algorithmiques et des voisinages de chargement pour parvenir à des solutions de très bonne qualité. La matheuristique basée sur la méthode de VNS est intégrée dans l’heuristique de génération de colonnes pour résoudre le MDMCMCm-VRPTW. Nous proposons une méthode exacte de post-traitement capable d’optimiser l’affectation des clients aux tournées de véhicules. Enfin, nous résolvons un RVRP qui survient dans le processus de collecte de l’huile d’olive en Tunisie à l’aide d’un algorithme exact de type branch-and-cu

Problèmes d'élaboration de tournées avec contraintes d'ordonnancement

International audienc

Taxonomy for Rich Vehicle Routing Problems

International audienceIn recent years methodological progress and the development of computer technologies has led to an increasing academic attention to new variants of vehicle routing problems including more complex constraints and objectives. This trend is stimulated by the complex characteristics of real-life vehicle routing applications. The families of these extended problems are often called Rich Vehicle Routing Problems (RVRPs). In this paper we propose to elaborate a generic taxonomic framework for the RVRP literature and to give a general and relevant definition of RVRPs. To this end, several papers addressing different issues related to RVRPs are selected and classified on the basis of the taxonomy attributes. After that, a cluster analysis of the selected papers is provided and discussed leading to the definition of RVRPs

A unified heuristic for solving rich variants of Orienteering Problems

International audienc

Heuristics for rich profitable tour problems

International audienceWe present a Rich variant of the Profitable Tour Problem (RPTP) arising when customer requests involve several products and multi-compartment vehicles are used. The RPTP addressed may be considered as a variant of the capacitated profitable tour problem with time windows and incompatibility constraints. We propose a Variable Neighborhood Search Algorithm embedded with an Adaptive Large Neighborhood Search for the RPTP. This method includes a perturbation phase based on the Ruin and Recreate paradigm. The efficiency of the proposed algorithm is assessed by solving the instances of the Orienteering Problem with Time Windows

Rich vehicle routing problems: From a taxonomy to a definition

International audienceOver the last years, several variants of multi-constrained Vehicle Routing Problems (VRPs) have been studied, forming a class of problems known as Rich Vehicle Routing Problems (RVRPs). The purpose of the paper is twofold: (i) to provide a comprehensive and relevant taxonomy for the RVRP literature and (ii) to propose an elaborate definition of RVRPs. To this end, selected papers addressing various cases are classified using the proposed taxonomy. Once the articles have been classified, a cluster analysis based on two discriminating criteria is performed and leads to the definition of RVRPs

Alternative formulations and improved bounds for the multi-depot fleet size and mix vehicle routing problem

In this paper, we compare different formulations of the multi-depot fleet size and mix vehicle routing problem (MDFSMVRP). This problem extends the multi-depot vehicle routing problem and the fleet size and mix vehicle routing problem, two logistics problems that have been extensively studied for many decades. This difficult vehicle routing problem combines complex assignment and routing decisions under the objective of minimizing fixed vehicle costs and variable routing costs. We first propose five distinct formulations to model the MDFSMVRP. We introduce a three-index formulation with an explicit vehicle index and a two-index formulation in which only vehicle types are identified. Other formulations are obtained by defining aggregated and disaggregated loading variables. The last formulation makes use of capacity-indexed variables. For each formulation, we summarize known and propose new valid inequalities, including symmetry breaking, lexicographic ordering, routing, and rounded capacity cuts. We then implement branch-and-cut and branch-and-bound algorithms for these formulations, and we fed them into a general purpose solver. We compare the bounds provided by the formulations on a commonly used set of instances in the MDFSMVRP literature, containing up to nine depots and 360 customers, and on newly generated instances. Our in-depth analysis of the five formulations shows which formulations tend to perform better on each type of instance. Moreover, our results have considerably improved available lower bounds on all instances and significantly improved quality of upper bounds that can be obtained by means of currently available methods